Complete guide · Reviews and reputation

How to deal with fake reviews on Google

How to spot fake Google reviews, report them to Google the right way, reply while you wait, and keep watch across every location with Review Shield.

DigitalMaas · Updated · 5 minutes read

The short answer

Google only removes a review when it breaks Google’s policies. Report it from your Business Profile, track the report in Google’s Reviews Management Tool and use your one-time appeal if Google finds no breach. Reply calmly in public while you wait, and keep asking every real customer for a review.

Updated 25 October 2026 with Google's current reporting steps, and how Review Shield helps.

A one-star review from someone who has never been a customer stings. Anyone with a Google Account can leave a review, so any business can be hit by fake, abusive or off-topic reviews. They drag your rating down, and they stay up because nobody has time to find them, check them against Google's rules and follow them up.

Here's how to deal with them calmly and properly.

First, take a breath

It's natural to feel angry. But a reply written in the heat of the moment can do more damage than the review. Take some time, then work through the steps below.

How to spot a review that may be fake

Look for signs like these:

  • You can't find them. No booking, order or visit matches the name or the date.
  • The details are wrong. They mention products you don't sell, staff who don't exist, or a location you don't have.
  • The reviewer's history is odd. A new account, or a pattern of one-star reviews for businesses like yours.
  • A sudden wave. Several negative reviews in a short time, often with similar wording.
  • It's about something else. Politics, a news story or a personal dispute, not a customer experience.

None of these proves a review is fake on its own. But they're good reasons to look closer.

What Google will and won't remove

Google only removes reviews that break its policies. That includes fake engagement, spam, off-topic reviews, offensive or hateful content, and conflicts of interest, such as a review from a competitor or a current or former employee.

Google won't remove a review just because it's negative, or because you disagree with it. Google says it doesn't get involved in disputes between businesses and customers.

How to report a review to Google

From your Business Profile:

  1. Go to your Business Profile and select Read reviews.
  2. Find the review and select the report option next to it.
  3. Choose the reason that fits best and send the report.

From Google's Reviews Management Tool: select your business, choose Report a new review for removal, select Report next to the review, pick a reason and submit. The same tool shows the status of every review you've reported.

Google says reviews typically take several days to evaluate. The status can be:

  • Decision pending: not yet evaluated.
  • Report reviewed - no policy violation: Google decided to keep it. You can then make a one-time appeal from the same tool.
  • Escalated: your appeal is being reviewed, and Google will email you the final decision.

Report each review once. If you think you're the target of a scam that uses negative reviews, for example someone demanding payment to stop, Google has a separate way to report it.

Reply while you wait

A review can stay up for days while Google checks it, or stay up for good if Google decides it doesn't break the rules. Other customers will read it, so reply.

  • Stay calm and polite. Write for the people reading, not the reviewer.
  • Say what you've checked. "We can't find a booking under this name or date."
  • Offer a way to talk. Give a phone number or email so they can contact you directly.
  • Don't accuse. Even if you're sure it's fake, an accusation in public looks defensive.

For example:

"Thanks for your feedback. We take every review seriously, but we can't find a visit or booking that matches this. Please call us on (02) 0000 0000 so we can look into it."

Protect your rating with real reviews

The best defence against a fake review is a steady flow of real ones. A single fake one-star review matters much less on a profile with plenty of recent, genuine reviews. Ask every happy customer, and make it easy with a review link or QR code. Read how to ask for Google reviews.

Keeping watch across every location with Review Shield

Checking every review at every location against Google's policies takes time most teams don't have. That's what Review Shield is for.

  • Detection. We check reviews at your locations against Google's review policies, and flag the ones that likely break them.
  • A report on each flagged review, saying what was flagged and why.
  • Historical scan (beta). We check each location's past reviews for policy breaches that were missed earlier.

Detection and the historical scan are included free for every paying Local Intelligence client. Our team switches them on for you, so there's nothing to install.

Review Shield detects and reports. Google decides what comes down. If you'd like help with that part, our optional managed service reports flagged reviews to Google and follows them up for you. You pay A$150 (ex GST) only for each review that's successfully removed. A review only counts once it's confirmed gone on live Google. If a removed review comes back, we report it again at no charge, or credit it.

See pricing, or ask your account manager to switch on Review Shield and run the historical scan.

Common questions